Rental Properties Need Work And Side Hustles Need Time. Dividend ETFs Are What One Investor Calls 'The Most Realistic Passive Income Source'

Benzinga and Yahoo Finance LLC may earn commission or revenue on some items through the links below.

The idea of earning money with little to no ongoing effort has long been a popular goal among investors. But one investor argued that many so-called passive income strategies aren't nearly as passive as they're made out to be.

Posting in Reddit's r/passive_income community recently, the investor said they work a regular 9-to-5 job and have come to a simple conclusion: "A lot of 'passive income' ideas are not actually passive."

The investor pointed to rental properties and other popular passive income approaches as examples.

Don't Miss:

• Own Rental Properties For Less Than The Cost Of Dinner — Shares Start At Just $20

• Institutional Real Estate Was Once Reserved For Pension Funds And Endowments. Accredited Investors Now Have Another Way In.

"Rental properties need management," they wrote. "Side hustles need time. Businesses need customers. Content needs consistency. Trading needs attention."

Instead, they said dividend and income-focused exchange-traded funds have become what they consider "the most realistic passive income source."

Building Cash Flow Without Another Job

The investor wasn't claiming dividend ETFs are a secret path to beating the market. In fact, they openly acknowledged that many income-focused funds may underperform growth-oriented investments over time.

"I don't think these funds are magic," they wrote. "I also don't think they always beat buying the underlying index or growth stocks."

Trending: Most budgeting apps ignore your investments. Empower doesn't — it syncs your 401(k), IRA, bank, and credit accounts into one real-time dashboard.

Their reasoning had less to do with maximizing returns and more to do with creating a second income stream. Even if the payments only cover a few bills, the investor said the income helps reduce dependence on a paycheck and makes financial progress feel more tangible.

"It makes progress visible," they wrote. "A monthly or quarterly cash payment is easier to track."

That idea resonated with many commenters. "The psychological benefit of seeing actual cash hit your account is underrated, especially when you're years away from needing it," one investor said. "Makes the whole wealth-building thing feel less theoretical."

The Debate Over Dividends Versus Growth

Not everyone agreed with the approach.

Several commenters argued that investors who are still working should focus on total return instead of income generation.

"Generally you'll be better off focusing on total returns, so growth stocks, while working a job," one person said.