‘Hazara Town’ Review: A Restrained but Deeply Affecting Doc Portrait of an Afghan Refugee Family Living in Limbo
A gauze of dust covers everything in the Pakistani desert city of Quetta, rendering just about everything the same shade of bleached, parched beige — an in-between color for an in-between place, where many residents await change with no clear timeline. In the city quarter of Hazara Town, named for over half a million residents from the ethnic Hazara community, displaced refugees from Afghanistan live in indefinite limbo: violently imperiled in their current sanctuary, but not yet granted asylum anywhere else. It’s a despairing holding pattern through which everyday life, with its more modest domestic challenges and occasional joys, nonetheless continues: Khadim Dai‘s patiently observed, intensely moving documentary “Hazara Town” sharply chronicles that simultaneous stasis and progress.
The first feature-length film by the Afghan-born, Los Angeles-based Dai is a family affair, centered on the director’s own stranded relatives: his sister-in-law, Sedeqa; his two young nieces, Machid and Mitra; and their doting grandparents. All are stranded in Quetta since fleeing Afghanistan, while Dai’s brother Hussain has forged ahead, laying the groundwork for a new life in Canada. Following him is no simple matter, however. The asylum application process is slow and selective, and whole chapters of family life pass by as they wait to be reunited: Preteen Mitra, in particular, doesn’t remember much of her father’s presence at home, and communication by phone and video only partially bridges the gap.
Returning to Pakistan several years after his own departure, Dai embeds himself in the household, his camera capturing both the intimate daily routines of a splintered family — in particular, the growth of two girls around their father’s absence — and wider currents of fear and sorrow in the Hazara community, where people increasingly find themselves as unsafe from ethnic and religious persecution as they were in the homeland they fled. Targeted killings are disturbingly commonplace, the rising death toll sporadically flashing on the screen with no further commentary.
Dai’s camera records no violence, but instead spends much time in the local cemetery where the dead are buried with little ceremony — their portraits displayed for a time as a memorial before they, too, vanish. Deft, detailed sound design balances the lonely reverberations of the desert wind against the industrious tap-tap-tapping of local stonemasons at work on various grave markers: At least some in this stymied community have much to do. But the cemetery isn’t presented only as a place of grief: It’s also a gathering spot for people otherwise granted little social space, and in some of the film’s most poignant tableaux, children chatter and play amidst these humble resting places.
Home, though, remains the most secure of spaces in an otherwise stateless existence: With its modest interior courtyard and few windows to the outside world, Dai’s family’s residence feels significantly turned inward. Though Machid and Mitra both go to school, classroom freedoms are curbed as Pakistan hands over responsibility for refugee education to the Taliban; it’s within cramped domestic walls that the girls assert their evolving personalities and interests, rapidly maturing before our eyes.
Machid, a studious bookworm with a love of Judy Blume, dreams of richer education opportunities in the United States, while the rest of the family pins their hopes on Canada — sold to them via effortfully cheerful video missives from Hussain, marveling at differences in culture and weather. Good news does arrive from North America, but not for everyone, and so the family is further fragmented. Dai films each individual flight from the back window of the departing taxi, splashed with a bucket of water for good luck, the drips distorting one last look at those left behind in the rearview.
Also an accomplished cinematographer, Dai shoots these individually unremarkable episodes of daily survival — and occasional celebration — with a grace and sensitivity that cumulatively builds to something more than just diaristic in effect: “Hazara Town” is a quietly emphatic statement of presence for lives all too easily disappeared, or dismissed as statistics. And while it provides no tidy resolution to this collective narrative, there’s at least a temporary, heart-filling interlude of reunion, before life pulls in a multitude of directions: For the refugee family, there’s as much anguish in movement as in stillness, but a shred of hope too.
Comments 0
Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Entertainment
Explore All
‘Ramayana’ Journey Across Asia Anchors Discovery Docuseries Marking Shashi Tharoor’s TV Hosting Debut (EXCLUSIVE)
Author and Indian lawmaker Shashi Tharoor is making his debut as a TV host, fronting “Itihasa: Ramayana Beyond Borders With Shashi Tharoor,̶...
Hearst Canvas Launches Frontier Collective Brand as U.K. Arm Builds Digital-Native Content Slate for YouTube
1 hour ago
‘The Altruists’ Review: Netflix FTX Series Fails to Get a Handle on Crypto Scammer Sam Bankman-Fried
1 hour ago
Airbnb Recreates Iconic ‘Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham’ Mansion for Film’s 25th Anniversary, With Kareena Kapoor Khan and Hrithik Roshan Hosting
3 hours agoWhat Happens When Documentary Makers Sell Their Footage to AI Aggregators?
3 hours agoWhats New
View All
‘Ramayana’ Journey Across Asia Anchors Discovery Docuseries Marking Shashi Tharoor’s TV Hosting Debut (EXCLUSIVE)
Saudi-led coalition intercepts Houthi missiles targeting Riyadh and south
Hearst Canvas Launches Frontier Collective Brand as U.K. Arm Builds Digital-Native Content Slate for YouTube
‘The Altruists’ Review: Netflix FTX Series Fails to Get a Handle on Crypto Scammer Sam Bankman-Fried
Trump's massive DC triumphal arch project dealt another blow by federal judge
Why is Pete Hegseth strengthening US military ties with Venezuela?
Gaza Syndrome: Why Israeli soldiers’ trauma erases Palestinian victims
'You will regret it': Angry resident confronts Democratic mayor during chaotic council meeting
Charting the world’s biggest IPOs as Anthropic overtakes SpaceX